Why (and how) you should review your nonprofit’s programs now

As 2026 draws to a close, your nonprofit may be preparing donor appeals, reviewing grant renewals and making spending decisions for 2027. Before renewing your commitment to existing programs, consider whether each offering still deserves the same investment. A year-end review can reveal funding gaps and help you direct limited resources toward your mission’s most pressing needs.

Connect spending with results

Start by reviewing each program’s year-to-date revenue and expenses, projected results through year end and proposed budget for next year. Investigate significant differences between budgeted and actual amounts. Lower spending might reflect efficiencies, but it could also signal unfilled positions or services that weren’t delivered.

For internal decision-making, consider each program’s full cost, including direct expenses and a reasonable share of administrative and fundraising costs. A program that appears self-supporting based on salaries and supplies alone may require substantial general operating support once you consider its broader resource needs.

Evaluate those costs alongside results. Useful measures might include participation, completion rates, cost per participant and progress toward specific outcomes. For example, a tutoring program could assess students’ academic progress, attendance and feedback from students and teachers. Programs don’t have to pay for themselves to merit continued support. The question is whether their contribution to your mission justifies the subsidies and whether your organization can sustain that commitment.

Listen before setting priorities

Numbers alone won’t explain why a program is struggling or whether it addresses an emerging need. Before finalizing next year’s spending priorities, seek input from participants, employees, volunteers, donors and community partners.

Ask what worked this year, what barriers limited participation and which needs remain unmet. Compare that feedback with relevant demographic trends and program results. Staff members who work directly with participants may identify scheduling or transportation problems that financial reports won’t reveal. Also weigh feedback according to stakeholders’ experience and knowledge. Donor enthusiasm deserves consideration, but funding decisions should reflect documented needs, program outcomes and your organization’s financial capacity.

Check next year’s funding

Next, assess whether the resources supporting each program will remain available in 2027. Identify:

  • Grants approaching expiration,

  • Uncertain renewals,

  • Changes in service revenue, and

  • Reliance on a small number of donors.

In addition, distinguish confirmed support from fundraising goals.

Review donor restrictions and grant agreements before proposing to move money between programs. Funds restricted to one purpose generally aren’t available to support another simply because management or the board changes its priorities.

Also prepare a cash-flow forecast. A year-end bank balance may include restricted gifts or money needed for upcoming obligations. Even a well-funded program can create cash pressure when payroll and other expenses come due before grant reimbursements arrive.

Budget for the transition

Your review may support expanding, redesigning, combining or discontinuing programs, so estimate the financial effects before acting. For example, closing a program won’t necessarily eliminate all its allocated costs. Rent, technology and administrative expenses may continue, while severance, contract termination charges or participant transition costs could create additional cash needs. Calculate the expenses you can actually avoid and the revenue you may lose.

For a new or expanded offering, budget for start-up costs, staffing, evaluation and ongoing support. Consider a limited pilot when demand or funding is uncertain. Finally, establish spending parameters and outcome measures, then revisit the budget as circumstances change.

Carry decisions into 2027

A year-end review is useful when its findings shape next year’s budget and operating plans. Document the reasons for significant changes, obtain appropriate approvals and assign responsibility for monitoring results. Contact us for help analyzing program costs and evaluating how proposed changes could affect your nonprofit’s financial position.

© 2026